CALL TO BID NOW - (260) 668-4488

Untitled Document
Pie #
Pie Description
Highest Bidder
Bid Amount

Pie #63

Boozy Pie Tri-fecta

Donated By: Gay's Hops-n-Schnapps

One Bourbon Caramel Apple Pecan Pie One Old Fashioned Cocktail Pie One Double Layer Pumpkin Pie

Priorty IAC

Pie #66

Peaches and Paws

Donated By: All Paws and Claws Veterinary Clinic

Classic peach pie with a PawPrint design :)

Tony Gay

Pie #64


Donated By: Mama's place


Bill's Professional Towing

Pie #43


Donated By: VESTIL MFG

full of fattening delight with butter, bourbon & pecans

One Vestil One Team

Pie #16

Yogi Bears Picnic Basket Peach Pie

Donated By: Yogi Bears Camp-Resort at Barton Lake Inc

Mouth watering Peach Pie

Mike @ Bent Wrench

Pie #84

Triple -Layer Mud Pie

Donated By: Northeastern Center

Oreo crust filled with a creamy chocolate and pudding layers, topped with cool whip and pecans.

Fremont American Legion

Pie #88

Georgia Pecan Pie

Donated By: Cardinal IG

Salty meets sweet in this lush, caramel southern classic.

Jimmy Johns

Pie #17

Grandma Betty's Dutch Apple Pie

Donated By: Barton Lake RV Sales

Deep Dish Dutch Apple Pie

Rees Inc.

Pie #30

Guaranteed Delicious

Donated By: Industrial Contracting & Engineering

This peach pie is guaranteed to be the best pie at your Thanksgiving feast!

Cardinal IG

Pie #96

Hagerty Hot and Sweet Yum Yum Pie

Donated By: Angola Fire Department

This pie will be smoking good with the perfect taste of all your favorite Thanksgiving spice and sassiness because it's made with a firey holiday love from Angola Fire Chief TR Hagerty.

Cardrinal IG

Pie #71

Lemon Chiffon Pie

Donated By: Dunham Motor Sales

Unlike more tart and dense lemon pies, this one has a soft lemon flavor and it’s ultra creamy, light and fluffy.

Shipe Well Drilling

Pie #49

Caramel Apple Pie

Donated By: Cameron Memorial Community Hospital Food Service

Its like Caramel Apples in a pie shell. Delicious Allergy Warning: Wheat, Dairy

Clearlake Electric Inc

Pie #55

Farmer's Wife Dutch Apple Pie

Donated By: Farmers & Merchants State Bank

A single crust apple pie with a luscious crumb topping.

Angola DQ

Pie #68


Donated By: YMCA

Oreo Crust, Layer one: Homemade caramel filling with pecans, crusted with sea salt. Middle layer: Rich whipping cream and creme fraiche mix. Topping is Chocolate Ganache, flavored with rum.

Clearlake Electric Inc

Pie #89

Peanut Butter Cup Pie

Donated By: Cardinal IG

A luscious candy combination in pie form. A supremely decadent end to a Thanksgiving feast!

Clearlake Electric

Pie #99

Donuts For A Year

Donated By: Toms Donuts

Winning bid receives 1 free dozen donuts, every month for an entire year!

Custom Bottling & Packaging

Pie #21

Lity's Famous Oreo Cheesecake

Donated By: Clear Lake Electric, Inc.

Silky smooth whipped Oreo cheesecake. Allergy: Contains milk, egg and dairy products.

All Paws & Claws

Pie #51

The Hatchery’s Famous Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Donated By: The Hatchery

Two layers of carrot cake with a cheesecake in the middle and all frosted with cream cheese frosting. Delicious! Contains : nuts,dairy,eggs,cinnamon,flour

Dilts Excavating

Pie #98

Aunt Sally's Famous Beavertail Pie

Donated By: Steuben County Sheriff's Department

Pretzel sticks with the best caramel and milk chocolate!!!!

Hamilton Fire Dep.

Pie #12

Harvest Peanut Butter Pie

Donated By: Howard Family Farms

Creamy peanut butter pie

The Dam Shop

Pie #27

Taxing your waistline dutch apple pie

Donated By: Andrews & Shipe LLC

Dutch apple pie made with delicious Stroh's orchard apples topped with brown sugar and real butter crumbles

Shipe Well Drilling

Pie #65

Mimi's French Cream Pie

Donated By: Angola City Police

Rich cream pie. Includes eggs.vanilla,cream and more.

Ryan, Dave Diesel

Pie #76

Living the Dream, Raspberry Cream

Donated By: Eva-Lution

Homemade crust topped vanilla pudding, then on top of that, homemade raspberry pie filling then topped off with made from scratch cool whip.


Pie #77


Donated By: Applebees

Pie tin with 2 $50 gift cards. As well as 2 bonus $10 cards. Plus a homemade coupon for 2 free Cheesecakes that I will make for the winner for Christmas. Vanilla Bean with Raspberry Coulis and Pistachio Chocolate Cheesecake with hazelnut chocolate ganache.

A & A Repair and Tires

Pie #83

Road Tar Pie (Cookies & Cream Pie)

Donated By: Avid Concepts

If you love oreo's then Road Tar Pie is for you!! This pie contains oreo, unsalted butter, heavy whipping cream, cream cheese, powdered sugar vanilla, and whipped cream.

Blake Murray

Pie #8

Momma's Mouth Watering Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

Donated By: Battle Creek Equipment

Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

Cody Harold Chevrolet Ford

Pie #31

Apple Pie Bullseye

Donated By: Thunder Lakes Indoor Shooting Range

This tasty apple pie is guaranteed to hit the spot at your family gathering this Thanksgiving!

Cody Harold Chevrolet Ford

Pie #3

Snickers Peanut Butter Brownie Pie

Donated By: Bill's Professional Towing & Repair

Pie crust filled with a layer of brownies and peanut butter nougat, topped with caramel and peanuts

Stoops Freightliner

Pie #14

Honey Bourbon Peach Pie

Donated By: Apis Enterprises

Apis Enterprises is your source for local honey and beeswax products! This pie is made with love, honey, peach, and bourbon. If you love our Jojo’s Jams Bourbon Honey Peach preserves, this is the pie for you! (Even if you haven’t tried the preserves, you will love this pie!)

Wagler Associates

Pie #39

Clear Peppermint Meringue Pie

Donated By: Angola Scout Troop 125

A light and refreshing crystal clear pie with peppermint filling and a fluffy peppermint meringue on top of a decadent chocolatey crust.

Patchwork & Sparkle Ceramics

Pie #70

RumChata pie


White chocolate Rumchata pie with Cinnamon Toast Crunch crust.

DeWayne Eck

Pie #87

Peanut Butter Paver Pie

Donated By: Jeremy Fugate Landscaping

Creamy peanut butter pie, topped with Reeses, whipped cream, and a chocolate paver patio.

T's Custom Carts & More

Pie #35

Save Yourself Therapeutic Peanut Butter Pie

Donated By: Kain's Farm & Garden LLC

Delicious peanut butter balls covered with smooth and creamy vanilla pudding, topped with delicious cool whip sprinkled with peanut butter. Allergy:Peanut Butter

Bill's Professional Towing Repair

Pie #36

Caramel Apple Pie

Donated By: Caleo Cafe

A homemade Angie's Cupcakes & Treats pie with a lard buttermilk crust filled with granny smith apples and topped with a chopped pecan, oat and brown sugar topping. Contains wheat, eggs, nuts and dairy products

Land of Lakes Loins Club

Pie #72

Snickerdoodle Cream Cheese Apple Pie

Donated By: Detail This

Made with snickerdoodle cookie crust with a layer of cream cheese,chopped apple pie filling and a snickerdoodle crumb topping.

Land of Lakes Lions Club

Pie #10

Pothole Pie

Donated By: Steuben County Highway Department

Rocky road crust filled with peanut butter and topped with whip cream and chocolate chunks.

Blackburn Transport

Pie #33

Friendly Feedings

Donated By: The friendly pampered chef

Not only A-mazing, but better than pie (sorry). Homemade pumpkin rolls (1 w/nuts and 1/wo nuts). Partnered with the best chocolate chips cookies around. * Contains nuts and dairy.

All Paws and Claws

Pie #62

Kentucky Bourbon Pecan Pie

Donated By: Custom Bottling & Packaging In

Kentucky Bourbon gives a kick to this Southern Classic. **contains nuts

Northern Industrial Flooring

Pie #2

White Chocolate Raspberry Cream Dream

Donated By: Custom Polish, INC.

It's a cake in a pie pan. Vanilla Cake with raspberry cream filling, Frosted with white chocolate raspberry frosting, then drizzled with dark chocolate. Contains: dairy, eggs, flour, sugar, raspberries and FD&C Red#40.

Dunam Motor Sales

Pie #6

Heavenly Peanut Butter Pie

Donated By: Habitat for Humanity of Northeast Indiana

It has a creamy, luscious texture and a rich peanut butter flavor. Absolutely scrumptious! - The pie does contain nuts.

Andwes and shipe

Pie #29

Peach Pie Perfection

Donated By: JICI Construction

This pie is built by the best baker in the Midwest. Every bite will be worth every penny!

Jim Grandin

Pie #67

DQ Cake

Donated By: Angola Dairy Queen

Dairy Queen famous cake crunch and fudge surrounded with chocolate and vanilla frozen soft serve.

The Dam Shop

Pie #85

The Full De-tail (Famous Carlo's Bakery Lobster Tails)

Donated By: Avid Concepts

These Lobster tails are the perfect combination of sweet crunchy goodness, baked to a golden brown and filled with Carlo's Bakery signature creamy filling. This will serve 8 people. This is Buddy's favorite and we're sure it will be yours too!

Michelle Teller

Pie #86

The Ultimate Detail (Trio of Carlo's Bakery Favorites)

Donated By: Avid Concepts

Not sure what pie to try from Carlo's Bakery? No Problem! Avid Concepts has put all 3 of the staple flavors o fall into a 3 pie pack. -Pecan Pie- piles of pecans mixed with the bakery's family secret ingredients and then packed into a homemade crust makes this the perfectly sweet and savory southern classic. -Pumpkin Pie- creamy, flavorful, perfectly spiced pumpkin filling inside a buttery, flakey shell on the outside. -Apple Pie- Perfect apple filling inside a buttery flakey shell with a buttery crumb topping.

Everidge Motorsales/Stroh IN

Pie #22

Angola is the Apple of my Eye Pie

Donated By: Downtown Angola Coalition (DA)

Home made crust, lush, supple apples, with exotic cinnamon, made by Author, Artist, and Poet; Angola's Own LouAnn Homan.

Detail This

Pie #52

Spectacular Red Velvet Cheesecake

Donated By: Lynn’s Cheesecakes LLC

Rich chocolate delight with cream cheese frosting. Treat your family to a very special desert! Contains: chocolate,red food coloring,eggs,dairy,buttermilk

KC Learning Center

Pie #5

Caramel Apple Walnut

Donated By: Steuben County Prosecutor's Office

Over 1 pound of orchard-fresh Michigan apples, walnut, cinnamon and a caramel icing.

Mike @ Bent Wrench

Pie #9

FSB Coconut Coin Pie

Donated By: Farmers State Bank

Coconut cream pie with whipped topping

Sevits Tree Service

Pie #24

White Chocolate Maple Cream Pie

Donated By: Fred Beck & Associates

Lush, velvety, cream pie, with Steuben County Sugar Maple Syrup! A fall favorite!

Everage Auto

Pie #25

2020 Unforgettable German Chocolate Cake

Donated By: Midwest Eye Consultants

3 layer German Chocolate Cake, with coconut and pecan frosting

Jim Grandin

Pie #57

Maple Cream Pie

Donated By: Dave Dilts Excavating

A rich flavored maple cream custard in a homemade flakey crust

Shipe Well Drilling

Pie #59

Salty Caramel Apple Pie

Donated By: Just Breathe Salt Room

Apple Pie with Caramel Sauce

Andwes and shipe

Pie #80

Ashley Fire Cherry Pie

Donated By: Ashley-Hudson Fire Dept.

Classic cherry pie

Barton Lake RV

Pie #82

Keyless Entry (Key Lime Pie)

Donated By: Avid Concepts

We feel this is the best key lime pie ever and are pretty positive you will agree!! This pie contains Key lime juice, lime zest, sour cream, sweetened condensed milk and a pecan crust.

Keagan & Ridge

Pie #92

Candy Crush

Donated By: Steuben County Communications and 911 Dispatchers

A peanut butter cream based pie, in a butterfinger graham cracker crust topped with crushed candy bars.


Pie #48

Pumpkin-Cream Cheese Pie

Donated By: Cameron Memorial Community Hospital Food Service

Cream Cheese and Pumpkin Pie in a pie shell two great tastes in one great pie. Allergy Warning: Wheat, Eggs, Dairy

DeWayne Eck Bobilya Chrysler

Pie #26

Crustless Cheese Cake

Donated By: The Heritage Club

A mouth-watering crustless cheesecake! Ricotta cheese, cream cheese and evaporated milk.

Cameron Memorial Community Hospital

Pie #38

Brown-Butter Bourbon Pecan Pie

Donated By: Angie's Cupcakes & Treats

a homemade buttermilk lard crust surrounds a sweet and nutty pecan pie with a twist - bourbon and brown butter

Nate's Lawn Care

Pie #53

Bourbon Pecan Pie

Donated By: Madsen Wire Products

A classic favorite! Gooey, sweet with vanilla, and don't forget the kick of bourbon. Need we say more?! Contains: Nuts, Eggs, Gluten

Land of Lakes Lions Club

Pie #61

Grandma's Butterscotch Pie

Donated By: First Federal Savings Bank of Angola

Contains: Milk, Salt, Vanilla, Flour, Egg Yolk, Brown Sugar, Butter

Jim Grandin

Pie #81

Hudson Fire Sugar-Free Cherry Pie

Donated By: Ashley-Hudson Fire Dept.

Classic sugar-free cherry pie

Daves Diesel

Pie #91

Miss Roxy's Kiddo's Candy Pie

Donated By: Miss Roxy's Daycare, LLC

Ingredients List - Creamy Peanut Butter, cool whip, cream cheese, with a gram cracker crust. Topped with all the kiddos favorite chocolate candies.

The Marina @ Lake Gage

Pie #1

Big D's Famous Great Outdoors Peanut Butter Pie

Donated By: Big D's Bait and Tackle/Archery

Just thinking this is another peanut butter pie...you better reconsider bidding on this pie, it is nothing you have had before!! Handcrafted whitetail deer with many secret family ingredients are sure to have your taste buds wanting another piece before the pie is gone!!

Pleasant Lake Lions Club

Pie #15

Choosy Moms' Peanut Butter Pie

Donated By: Little River a Capella Show Chorus

Creamy peanut butter filling topped with whipped cream and peanut butter chips.

Jenn Hagerty

Pie #41

The Fred Smith Memorial pie

Donated By: Avid Concepts

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie: has whip cream,cream cheese,peanut butter,sugar,hot fudge and Resse's Peanut Butter cups in a graham cracker crust. Allergy warning has Peanuts and dairy products in it.

Jason Hutter

Pie #44

Nutella Chocolate Mousse Pie

Donated By: Angola Boy Scout Troop 125

A light creamy chocolate mousse with a hint of hazelnut in a chocolate crust - this pie is a chocolate lover's delight!! Allergy warning: includes wheat, tree nuts, dairy, and soy.

First Federal Savings Bank Angola

Pie #58

Coconut Cream Pie

Donated By: Static Salon

Made from scratch tasty coconut cream filling in a flaky crust Topped with cool whip

Jim Grandin

Pie #73

Not Sorry Pie

Donated By: MTD Clean Sweep LLC Lawn Care

Reese's Peanut Butter Pie

All Paws & Claws

Pie #95

Dutch Apple Pie

Donated By: Ashley-Hudson Fire Department

dutch apple pie

Angola Canvas

Pie #97

Apple Crumb Pie

Donated By: D A S Services

Big D's Bait & Tackle

Pie #4

Pies-Cream Cake

Donated By: Angola Dairy Queen Grill & Chill


Fremont Athletic Boosters

Pie #23

Oil Change Pie

Donated By: Everage Auto

Black Bottom, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie.....with Free Oil Change; Lagrange Location

Northern Industrial Flooring

Pie #42

Nuts About Braces

Donated By: ELD Orthodontics

Delicious Peanut Butter Pie Allergy warning: contains nuts, dairy, eggs, wheat

Nate's Lawn Care

Pie #46

Chess Pie

Donated By: FIST-Forever Improving Steuben Together

This is a very old Southern recipe. It's a very sweet, rich pie which cannot be described as anything but marvelous!

Everage Auto

Pie #47

Mama's salsa pie and chips

Donated By: Boyscout pokagon district round table

A quart jar of the most delicious homemade salsa with chips

Achieve Physical Therapy

Pie #60

Maple Buttermilk Pie

Donated By: First Federal Savings Bank of Angola

Creamy Maple Custard Pie Contains: Eggs, Dairy, Flour

Everage Auto

Pie #79

Old Fashion Oatmeal Pie

Donated By: MJs Uptown Antiques

Bid D's Bait & Tackle

Pie #93

Shingle Roof Apple Pie


This delicious homemade apple pie tatse better than homemade with flavors of cinnamon and nutmeg. Featuring a shingled roof effect for the top pie crust

Northern Industrial Flooring

Pie #28

Black Bottom Pie

Donated By: Madsen Wire Products

An old fashion favorite of dense semi-sweet chocolate custard, or black bottom, with a light chiffon custard topped with chocolate shavings. *Contains: flour, dairy, eggs*

Thad Wright

Pie #40

Fittsister Pie

Donated By: Fitt4life

apple walnut pie. Eat the pie then come in and work it off!

R.H. Wood Designs

Pie #7

Chocolate Moose Quake Pie

Donated By: Angola Moose Lodge 1568

A delicious, melt in your mouth blend of German Chocolate, cream cheese, eggs, oil, flour, real butter, powdered sugar, coconut and pecans.

Lagrange Products

Pie #18

Pineapple on the beach.

Donated By: Heritage club

Pineapple upside down cake / pecans

The Bell Family

Pie #74

For you Blue

Donated By: MTD Clean Sweep LLC Lawn Care

Brownie Pie

Ashley-Hudson Fire Dept.

Pie #11

Pecan pie

Donated By: Indiana Marine Products: Sales Dept.

Traditional pecan pie.

Barton Lake RV

Pie #13

Old Fashioned Lemon Sponge

Donated By: Magical Vacation Planner by Tess

A family holiday tradition! A perfect balance of sweet and tart, this pie has a lemon custard pie filling with a spongy lemon topping baked to a golden brown. After you taste it, you will crave this pie every year!

Jennifer Marshall

Pie #19

Deep Dish Lemon Supreme Pie

Donated By: Metz Christian Church

Tart lemony filling over a layer of sweet, creamy cream cheese, and topped with whipped cream.

Sevits Tree Service

Pie #20

Festive Fruit, Nut & Seed "Pie" (for birds)

Donated By: Friends of Pokagon, Inc.

Birds like holiday treats, too! This 2.5 pound, all-natural wreath-shaped "pie" comes with a hearty ribbon for hanging outdoors, so your feathered friends can celebrate the bounty of the season. Contains a variety of nuts, seeds, dried fruit, gelatin and corn syrup. Not for human consumption.

Rickles Pickles

Pie #45

Kentucky Derby Pie

Donated By: FIST-Forever Improving Steuben Together

This Kentucky Derby Pie is a chocolate chip pecan cookie in a pie crust!

William Stitt

Pie #50

pumpkin delight bars

Donated By: Wall lake tavern

has a cookie crest top with pumpkin,cream cheese filling with dried cherries. Top with pecans, white chips,and coconut.

Chad & Sandy Owens

Pie #56

Eyefull of Apple Pie Pizza

Donated By: Midwest Eye Consultants

Apple pie that is like a pizza.

Yogi Bear

Pie #90

Salted Carmel Dark Chocolate Pie

Donated By: Tyler Benner - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

Decadent dark chocolate ganache and sweet carmel sprinkled with sea salt. A salty, sweet treat for anyone in your family. Allergy: dairy

Blake Murray

Pie #94

Handyman Special Pumpkin Pie


This delicious pumpkin pie features a soft flaky crust with homemade pumpkin pie filling with flavors of cinnamon vanilla and nutmeg

Ashley-Hudson Fire Dept.

Pie #34

Run for the Roses Pie

Donated By: JTR Acres

A classic southern pie with chocolate chips, walnuts, and flavored with bourbon.

Lagrange Products

Pie #37

Gluten Free Pumpkin Pie

Donated By: Mat Mat'rs

An Angie's Cupcakes & Treats homemade gluten free pumpkin pie with a tub of cool whip

Cassie & Todd

Pie #75

A gluten-free pack of nuts stick together

Donated By: pack 3186

a gluten free crust will delicious pecan in a sweet syrup.

Adam & Jessica Witmer