Call 260-668-4488 to Bid Now!
| Pie # | Item | Highest Bidder | Bid Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| #68 |
Cookie Monster Cheesecake
Donated By: Four Seasons Design & Remodeling, Inc.
Chocolate chip cheesecake loaded with Oreo cookies and chocolate chip cookies, on a cookie crust.
Allergy Warning: Milk |
All Paws | $350.00 |
| #97 |
Zoning Violation Cheesecake
Donated By: Steuben County Building & Planning
Chocolate strawberry swirl cheesecake!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Sevits Tree Service | $350.00 |
| #98 |
Pamper Pie
Donated By: Panache Salon
Forget the fork — this pie is served with pampering self-care! This isn’t your typical pie — it’s a collection of luxurious pampering experiences. From revitalizing hair treatments to soothing spa services, every “slice” of this pie offers a taste of relaxation. No sugar, no calories — just pure indulgence!
This pie includes: Rosemary Mint Hand & Body Wash, Body Lotion, and Candle set. Services: Lash Lift & Tint with Rachael, Spa Hair Treatment with Morgan, Makeup Application with Liz, Haircut with Morgyn, Eyebrow Wax & Color with Heather, Manicure with Roshelle, Pedicure with Mishayla, Facial with Sydney, and Luminary Nail Application with Emma! Total value of over $600! |
All Paws | $350.00 |
| #13 |
Angola Is the Apple of My Eye
Donated By: Angola Main Street
This pie’s got Main Street magic baked right in! The “Angola Is the Apple of My Eye Pie” is a Dutch apple dream — packed with sweet and savory apples, a buttery flaky crust, and plenty of local pride. It’s sweet and totally irresistible… kind of like downtown!
Baked with love (and maybe a secret ingredient or two), this pie is the perfect mix of cozy comfort and small-town flavor. So, grab your fork and bid high — because supporting Shop for a Cop never tasted so good! |
Susan Catterall | $300.00 |
| #14 |
Coconut Cream Pie
Donated By: YMCA of Steuben County
Vanilla & Coconut cream filling, topped with meringue & toasted coconut.
Allergy Warning: Eggs |
Cory & Jennie Archbold | $300.00 |
| #50 |
The Excavator Pecan Pie
Donated By: Rapid Rental
Dig into this rich caramel-y , gooey nutty filling in a graham cracker crust.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts |
Croxton & Roe Insurance | $300.00 |
| #33 |
Salted Caramel Apple Pie
Donated By: The Marina at Lake Gage
Buttery crust with spiced apple filing and a salted caramel sauce.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Everidge Motor sales of Stroh | $275.00 |
| #51 |
Cinna-Loader apple pie
Donated By: Rapid Rental
Push the sweet flavor of this classic apple pie in a cinnamon roll crust topped with cinnamon roll lattice and the jobs complete with an icing drizzle on top.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Wheat |
Nate's Lawncare | $275.00 |
| #65 |
No Bake Peanut Butter Dream
Donated By: Countryside Towing
Peanut butter pie!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Peanuts |
Orland Repair | $275.00 |
| #92 |
Peanut Butter Delight
Donated By: Clay's Family Restaurant
Creamed peanut butter & cream cheese, graham cracker crust. Whipped topping drizzled with chocolate fudge & caramel sauce.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs & Peanuts |
Indiana Physical Therapy | $275.00 |
| #60 |
Butterfinger Caramel Crunch
Donated By: Rent-A-Center
Yummy no bake creamy peanut butter & caramel with a Butterfinger candy crunch.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Peanuts |
Awning and Sign Contractors | $250.00 |
| #99 |
A Bark Worse than the Bite
Donated By: The Working Dog Boarding & Grooming
Peanut Butter pie!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Peanuts |
All Paws | $250.00 |
| #72 |
CertaPie Delight
Donated By: CertaPro Painters
Peanut Butter with a base coat of Milk Chocolate with a finish coat of White Chocolate.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs & Peanuts |
Univertical LLC | $220.00 |
| #2 |
Everything but the Crust Pie
Donated By: The Mill District
The Mill District famous Everything Cheese Ball served up “pie” style.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Wheat |
Rees, Inc. | $200.00 |
| #4 |
All in 1 Bite
Donated By: All in 1 Construction and Remodeling LLC
A decadent chocolate pecan pie that will leave you savoring every bite.
Allergy Warning: Tree Nuts |
Kent & Candy Carlin | $200.00 |
| #5 |
Mosaic Pie
Donated By: Pharoahs Car Club Of Angola
A pie made of individual pies looks like a church window apples, cherries, blueberries individual pieces mosaic to make a beautiful tasteful creation.
Allergy Warning: Lactose |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #11 |
Black Belt Bites: Fall Pie Edition
Donated By: Impact Martial Arts
This is a platter of pumpkin and apple pies sponsored by Impact Martial Arts black belts.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #12 |
Peaches and Cream Pie
Donated By: Steuben County Crimestoppers
This amazing pie incorporates aspects of peach cobbler, cheesecake and pie into one luscious dessert.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #22 |
Apple in the Park
Donated By: Steuben County Parks
Apple pie!
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Soy |
Scott Schwartz | $200.00 |
| #25 |
Good With Time Key Lime
Donated By: Pleasant Lake Montessori School
A Wonderful refreshing Key Lime Pie made by the Upper Elementary Students of Pleasant Lake Montessori. It is made with hard work, dedication and a hint of love to please your taste buds.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
RH Wood Design | $200.00 |
| #28 |
Elwood's Blueberry Pie
Donated By: Elwood Staffing
Classic Blueberry Lattice Pie.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #30 |
Bourbon Pecan Sweet Potato Pie
Donated By: Baril Coatings USA
Crunchy, caramelized nuttiness, with hints of vanilla. Held together with sweet cream and earthy custard. Perfect for fans of both sweet potato and pecan pie!
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts, Corn Syrup |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #35 |
Ashley-Hudson Sugar Cream Pie
Donated By: Ashley-Hudson Fire Department
Wix Sugar Cream Pie.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts & Wheat |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #81 |
Big Rig Pecan Pie
Donated By: Stoops Freightliner - Western Star
Loaded with pecans, this pie is built for flavor and fuel! A rich, gooey pecan pie with a touch of maple under the hood- sweet, nutty, and guaranteed to keep you truckin'. Bonus: It's gluten and dairy free, so everyone can grab a slice and hit the road happy!
Allergy Warning: Tree Nuts |
Awning and Sign Contractors | $200.00 |
| #82 |
Bougie, Chocolate Pecan Pie
Donated By: Lakeland Rehab and Healthcare
Decadently smooth chocolate meets toasted pecans in this indulgent twist on tradition — sophisticated, sweet, and unapologetically bougie.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs & Tree Nuts |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #86 |
A Pear of Hearts
Donated By: Heart To Heart Hospice
Double heart pear upside down cake!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Musson Builders | $200.00 |
| #88 |
Peanut Butter Dreams
Donated By: Taskmaster Components
Peanut Butter pie that taste like heaven.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Peanuts |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #91 |
Possum Pie
Donated By: Clay's Family Restaurant
Creamy Chocolate Fudge base with White Chocolate cream topping in a Clay's homemade pie crust.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs & Wheat |
Stoops Freightliner | $200.00 |
| #54 |
Lion Peanut Butter Pie
Donated By: Orland Lions Club
Creamy peanut butter with cream cheese!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Peanuts |
First Federal Savings Bank of Angola | $175.00 |
| #74 |
Apple Pie
Donated By: Lawnscape Garden Center
A delicious homemade classic apple pie.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Nutmeg, Cinnamon |
Jim Grandin | $175.00 |
| #107 |
Most Valuable Pie
Donated By: Angola Kids League
A delicious Heath, chocolate pudding pie!
|
Mark Cowen | $150.00 |
| #3 |
Marshmallow Whip Cheesecake Heaven
Donated By: Pharoahs Car Club of Angola
Graham cracker crust , Marshmallow whip, strawberries, Cream Cheese, cool whip.
Allergy Warning: Milk |
Gillen Mechanical | $150.00 |
| #6 |
Possum Pie
Donated By: The Heritage Club
A layered pie of cream cheese, chocolate and whipped cream.
Allergy Warning: Milk |
Rick & Brenda Shipe | $150.00 |
| #17 |
A Slice of Hope
Donated By: Turning Point of Steuben
Apple Pie!
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts, Peanuts, Wheat |
Todd Squires | $150.00 |
| #20 |
Granny's Apple Pie
Donated By: First Federal Savings Bank of Angola
Woven Apple Crumble Pie.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Wheat |
Angie and Scott Gruner | $150.00 |
| #24 |
Leaders Apple Crumble
Donated By: Pleasant Lake Montessori Students and Staff
Scrumptious Apple Crumble Pie made with love by the wonderful Lower Elementary Class of Pleasant Lake Montessori School.
Allergy Warning: Eggs & Wheat |
Troy Book, Speedway Construction Products | $150.00 |
| #32 |
Apple Crisp Pie
Donated By: Fremont Middle School
Apple Crisp Pie!
|
Detail This | $150.00 |
| #42 |
The Perfect Bite
Donated By: EL Dellinger Orthodontics
This rich, sweet classic pecan pie was made with love by Dr. Eric himself. It has a flaky and buttery crust with gooey caramel-like filling topped with pecans.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts |
Angie and Scott Gruner | $150.00 |
| #46 |
Blue and Gold Dump Cake
Donated By: Fremont Scouts Cub Pack 3186
Themed after the annual Blue and Gold celebration of Cub Packs, this Blueberry Lemon Dump Cake was cooked in a Dutch Oven exactly how it's done during campouts.
Allergy Warning: Wheat |
Bills Professional Towing | $150.00 |
| #63 |
LPI Pie
Donated By: LaGrange Products
Apple Pie!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Eggs |
Musson Builders | $150.00 |
| #64 |
Saleen Pumpkin Pie
Donated By: Dream Solutions
Pumpkin pie!
|
Tractor Supply | $150.00 |
| #79 |
Peanut Butter Bliss
Donated By: Pro Concrete Flooring Solutions
Chocolate crust with peanut butter pie filling and whipped cream.
Allergy Warning: Peanuts |
Baril Coatings | $150.00 |
| #84 |
Under the Awning Peach Lush Pie
Donated By: Awning & Sign Contractors
A decadent and luscious slice of heaven! This delicious pie is loaded with juicy peaches, fluffy whipped topping, rich cream cheese, and sprinkled with the perfect amount of cinnamon magic! Sweet, smooth, and oh-so-delicious, this pie is sure to be the talk of the dessert table!
Allergy Warning: Milk & Cinnamon |
Angie and Scott Gruner | $150.00 |
| #102 |
Peanut Butter Deliciousness
Donated By: Maagnificent Lawn Care
A traditional peanut butter pie.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Peanuts |
Gillen Mechanical | $150.00 |
| #105 |
For the Birds - Festive Nut and Seed "pie"
Donated By: Friends of Pokagon, Inc
All natural wreath shaped pie made with a variety of nuts, seed, dried fruit, gelatin and corn syrup. Comes with a festive hearty ribbon for hanging outdoors.
**NOT for human consumption** |
All Paws & Claws | $150.00 |
| #89 |
Blueberry Cheesecake Pie
Donated By: Avid Concepts
Blueberry cheesecake.
Allergy Warning: Milk, Eggs & Wheat |
Cindi Miller | $130.00 |
| #8 |
Gotta Go Dirt Pie
Donated By: North Wayne Cruise-In
Butter, cream cheese, vanilla pudding ,Oreos.
Allergy Warning: Milk |
Stan & Kim Michael | $125.00 |
| #80 |
The Long Haul Cherry Pie
Donated By: Stoops Freightliner - Western Star
Put the pedal to the metal for this cherry-packed beauty! Juicy cherries, buttery crust, and just the right touch of sweetness to keep you fueled up for the long haul.
Allergy Warning: Milk & Wheat |
Jim Grandin | $125.00 |
| #103 |
Grandmas Apple Pie
Donated By: Maagnificent Taxidermy
Traditional apple pie!
|
Bomag Group | $120.00 |
| #9 |
Pumpkin Plymouth
Donated By: North Wayne Cruise-In
Vanilla pudding, milk, pumpkin pie spice, butter.
Allergy Warning: Milk |
Mama's 2.0 | $100.00 |
Timing: pre-query=0.0013s; fetch+render=0.0003s